Skip to contents

Model and source

Szederkenyi et al. measured the penetration of topically applied 2% O/W creams through excised skin mounted in a dynamic “skin-on-a-chip” microfluidic diffusion chamber, and described every measured cumulative-permeation curve with the same three-compartment linear ODE model (Section 2.7, Eq 1). The three compartments are the layers of the skin obtained by spatially discretising a diffusion-convection equation: a constant zero-order input kin from the cream enters the outermost layer, neighbouring layers exchange drug by diffusion (kd, both directions) and by inward convection (kc), and the deepest layer loses drug at the first-order rate kout. The only observed quantity is the deepest-layer state, y = x3, which the authors fit to the cumulative drug mass permeated into the receptor fluid per cm^2 of diffusion surface.

The model was fitted separately to each experiment’s mean curve, giving 13 independent parameter sets (S1 Table). nlmixr2lib ships each as its own model:

cases <- tibble::tribble(
  ~model,                                    ~experiment,                                ~figure,  ~tend, ~mass_unit,
  "Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_rt6h",          "Caffeine, rat skin, 23.5 C, 6 h",          "4A",     6,     "ug/cm^2",
  "Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_32c6h",         "Caffeine, rat skin, 32 C, 6 h",            "4B",     6,     "ug/cm^2",
  "Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_rt12h",         "Caffeine, rat skin, 23.5 C, 12 h",         "5",      12,    "ug/cm^2",
  "Szederkenyi_2024_dexamethasone",          "Dexamethasone acetate, rat skin",          "6A",     6,     "ng/cm^2",
  "Szederkenyi_2024_piroxicam",              "Piroxicam, rat skin",                      "6B",     6,     "ng/cm^2",
  "Szederkenyi_2024_indomethacin",           "Indomethacin, rat skin",                   "6C",     6,     "ng/cm^2",
  "Szederkenyi_2024_diclofenac",             "Diclofenac, rat skin",                     "6D",     6,     "ug/cm^2",
  "Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_vaseline24h",   "Caffeine, mouse skin, vaseline 24 h",      "8A",     5,     "ug/cm^2",
  "Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_vaseline96h",   "Caffeine, mouse skin, vaseline 96 h",      "8B",     5,     "ug/cm^2",
  "Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_imiquimod24h",  "Caffeine, mouse skin, imiquimod 24 h",     "8C",     5,     "ug/cm^2",
  "Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_imiquimod96h",  "Caffeine, mouse skin, imiquimod 96 h",     "8D",     5,     "ug/cm^2",
  "Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_ear_acetone",   "Caffeine, mouse ear, acetone control",     "10A",    5,     "ug/cm^2",
  "Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_ear_tncb",      "Caffeine, mouse ear, TNCB allergic",       "10B",    5,     "ug/cm^2"
)
uis <- lapply(cases$model, function(nm) rxode2::rxode(readModelDb(nm)))
names(uis) <- cases$model
knitr::kable(cases |> dplyr::select(model, experiment, figure))
model experiment figure
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_rt6h Caffeine, rat skin, 23.5 C, 6 h 4A
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_32c6h Caffeine, rat skin, 32 C, 6 h 4B
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_rt12h Caffeine, rat skin, 23.5 C, 12 h 5
Szederkenyi_2024_dexamethasone Dexamethasone acetate, rat skin 6A
Szederkenyi_2024_piroxicam Piroxicam, rat skin 6B
Szederkenyi_2024_indomethacin Indomethacin, rat skin 6C
Szederkenyi_2024_diclofenac Diclofenac, rat skin 6D
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_vaseline24h Caffeine, mouse skin, vaseline 24 h 8A
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_vaseline96h Caffeine, mouse skin, vaseline 96 h 8B
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_imiquimod24h Caffeine, mouse skin, imiquimod 24 h 8C
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_imiquimod96h Caffeine, mouse skin, imiquimod 96 h 8D
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_ear_acetone Caffeine, mouse ear, acetone control 10A
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_ear_tncb Caffeine, mouse ear, TNCB allergic 10B

Population

There is no human or animal population in the usual sense: each model describes the mean of three replicate skin samples (n = 3 per experiment, figure captions) in one ex vivo set-up. The chamber has a 0.5 cm^2 diffusion surface between the cream-filled donor chamber and a receptor chamber perfused with peripheral perfusion fluid (147 mM NaCl, 4 mM KCl, 2.3 mM CaCl2, pH 7.4) at 4 uL/min; receptor fluid was collected every 30 or 15 min (Section 2.4).

  • Healthy-skin experiments (caffeine at room temperature and at 32 C, and the four anti-inflammatory creams) used tape-stripped abdominal skin of rats weighing 599-615 g (Sections 2.4 and 2.6).
  • Psoriasiform dermatitis was induced in male C57BL/6J mice (21.7-27.0 g) with 0.0625 g of 5% imiquimod cream on the shaved back (once for the 24 h group, daily for the 96 h group), with vaseline-treated time-matched controls (Section 2.5).
  • Allergic contact dermatitis was induced in male C57BL/6J mice (24.2-31.2 g) by sensitising the abdomen with 3% TNCB (controls: acetone) and challenging both ears with 1% TNCB on day 5; the ear tissue was mounted in the chamber (Section 2.5).

Caffeine was assayed by NanoDrop spectrophotometry at 273 nm and the anti-inflammatory drugs by LC-MS/MS. The same information is stored in each model’s population metadata:

str(uis[["Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_rt6h"]]$population)
#> List of 11
#>  $ species      : chr "ex vivo (rat abdominal skin)"
#>  $ n_subjects   : int 3
#>  $ n_studies    : int 1
#>  $ system       : chr "Skin-on-a-chip microfluidic diffusion chamber (polydimethylsiloxane in an aluminium frame): a 0.5 cm^2 diffusio"| __truncated__
#>  $ tissue       : chr "Full-thickness 18-mm punches of shaved, depilated and tape-stripped (10 strips) abdominal skin of rats weighing"| __truncated__
#>  $ dose_range   : chr "O/W cream (46% petrolatum basis ointment, 4% paraffin oil, 38% purified water, 10% propylene glycol) containing"| __truncated__
#>  $ temperature  : chr "room temperature, approximately 23.5 C (air-conditioned laboratory)"
#>  $ sampling     : chr "Receptor fluid collected every 30 or 15 min for 6 h; caffeine in the collected receptor fluid by NanoDrop spect"| __truncated__
#>  $ disease_state: chr "healthy (intact skin)"
#>  $ regions      : chr "Hungary (Budapest)"
#>  $ notes        : chr "Mean of n = 3 replicate skin samples (Figure 4A caption); the model was fitted to the mean curve by minimising "| __truncated__

Source trace

Every ini() value carries an in-file comment pointing to its row of S1 Table. All four parameters were estimated (Matlab fmincon, Eq 7) on the linear scale and are reported without uncertainty; nlmixr2lib stores them log-transformed.

Model element Source location
d/dt(skin_slab1), d/dt(skin_slab2), d/dt(skin_slab3) Section 2.7, Eq 1 (states x1, x2, x3)
Output cum_mass <- skin_slab3 Section 2.7 (“The only measured concentration is y = x3”); figure y-axes (cumulative mass per cm^2)
lkin, lkdiff, lkconv, lkout (paper kin, kd, kc, kout) S1 Table, one row per model
Zero initial conditions Figures 4-10 (all simulated curves start at 0); S1 Table reports no initial-condition estimates
Time unit (h) Figure x-axes
Mass units (ug/cm^2 or ng/cm^2) Figure y-axes; Table 2
s1 <- dplyr::bind_rows(lapply(cases$model, function(nm) {
  th <- uis[[nm]]$theta
  tibble::tibble(
    model = nm,
    kin = exp(th[["lkin"]]),
    kd = exp(th[["lkdiff"]]),
    kc = exp(th[["lkconv"]]),
    kout = exp(th[["lkout"]])
  )
}))
knitr::kable(s1, digits = 6, caption = "Back-transformed parameters (compare S1 Table).")
Back-transformed parameters (compare S1 Table).
model kin kd kc kout
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_rt6h 7.4371 0.033600 3.37780 0.029300
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_32c6h 11.8667 0.031900 3.66370 0.019300
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_rt12h 9.2316 0.019800 2.04090 0.000042
Szederkenyi_2024_dexamethasone 874.9814 0.000034 0.22190 0.000039
Szederkenyi_2024_piroxicam 821.8726 0.000012 0.37762 0.000016
Szederkenyi_2024_indomethacin 111.8016 0.000646 0.26900 0.000643
Szederkenyi_2024_diclofenac 52.0705 0.027900 0.36810 0.223100
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_vaseline24h 3.6499 0.120600 30.64610 0.336500
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_vaseline96h 3.1878 0.215000 261.08480 0.220700
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_imiquimod24h 10.0399 0.027200 3.13610 0.000304
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_imiquimod96h 7.5925 0.063700 7.40990 0.000035
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_ear_acetone 0.5846 1.849400 1017.20590 0.000738
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_ear_tncb 1.1352 0.034700 9.06110 0.123600

Simulation

The models carry no between-sample variability and no residual error, so each is solved once at its typical values. There are no dose records: the cream is the constant input kin.

sim <- dplyr::bind_rows(lapply(seq_len(nrow(cases)), function(i) {
  ev <- rxode2::et(seq(0, cases$tend[i], by = 0.05))
  s <- rxode2::rxSolve(uis[[cases$model[i]]], events = ev, rtol = 1e-10, atol = 1e-12)
  tibble::tibble(
    model = cases$model[i],
    experiment = cases$experiment[i],
    figure = cases$figure[i],
    mass_unit = cases$mass_unit[i],
    time = s$time,
    cum_mass = s$cum_mass
  )
}))

Replicate published figures

plot_cases <- function(figs, title) {
  sim |>
    dplyr::filter(figure %in% figs) |>
    dplyr::mutate(panel = paste0("Fig ", figure, ": ", experiment, " (", mass_unit, ")")) |>
    ggplot(aes(time, cum_mass)) +
    geom_line(colour = "red") +
    facet_wrap(~panel, scales = "free_y") +
    labs(x = "Time (h)", y = "Cumulative mass permeated per cm^2", title = title)
}
plot_cases(c("4A", "4B", "5"), "Caffeine through healthy rat skin") +
  labs(caption = "Replicates the simulated curves of Figures 4A, 4B and 5 of Szederkenyi 2024.")

plot_cases(c("6A", "6B", "6C", "6D"), "Anti-inflammatory creams through rat skin") +
  labs(caption = "Replicates the simulated curves of Figure 6 of Szederkenyi 2024.")

plot_cases(c("8A", "8B", "8C", "8D"), "Caffeine through control and psoriatic mouse skin") +
  labs(caption = "Replicates the simulated curves of Figure 8 of Szederkenyi 2024.")

plot_cases(c("10A", "10B"), "Caffeine through control and allergic mouse ear tissue") +
  labs(caption = "Replicates the simulated curves of Figure 10 of Szederkenyi 2024.")

Validation

The paper reports no NCA, so PKNCA does not apply. The checks below compare the packaged models against the printed numbers that the paper does give, and against the closed-form solution of Eq 1.

Final cumulative mass against the published curves

The final value of each red simulated curve in Figures 4, 5, 6, 8 and 10 was read off the figure by the maintainers (precision about 2-3% of the axis range). The packaged models reproduce every one within 5%.

digitised <- tibble::tribble(
  ~figure, ~fig_end,
  "4A",    37.0,
  "4B",    61.0,
  "5",     101,
  "6A",    830,
  "6B",    1560,
  "6C",    140,
  "6D",    67.5,
  "8A",    8.75,
  "8B",    9.65,
  "8C",    43.3,
  "8D",    35.5,
  "10A",   2.90,
  "10B",   4.08
)
final <- sim |>
  dplyr::group_by(model, figure, mass_unit) |>
  dplyr::filter(time == max(time)) |>
  dplyr::ungroup() |>
  dplyr::select(model, figure, mass_unit, time, cum_mass) |>
  dplyr::inner_join(digitised, by = "figure") |>
  dplyr::mutate(pct_diff = 100 * (cum_mass / fig_end - 1))
stopifnot(nrow(final) == nrow(cases), all(abs(final$pct_diff) < 5))
final |>
  dplyr::rename(
    "Figure" = figure,
    "Units" = mass_unit,
    "Time (h)" = time,
    "Simulated" = cum_mass,
    "Published (figure)" = fig_end,
    "Difference (%)" = pct_diff
  ) |>
  knitr::kable(digits = 2)
model Figure Units Time (h) Simulated Published (figure) Difference (%)
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_rt6h 4A ug/cm^2 6 36.87 37.00 -0.34
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_32c6h 4B ug/cm^2 6 60.96 61.00 -0.06
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_rt12h 5 ug/cm^2 12 100.82 101.00 -0.18
Szederkenyi_2024_dexamethasone 6A ng/cm^2 6 833.04 830.00 0.37
Szederkenyi_2024_piroxicam 6B ng/cm^2 6 1541.58 1560.00 -1.18
Szederkenyi_2024_indomethacin 6C ng/cm^2 6 138.70 140.00 -0.93
Szederkenyi_2024_diclofenac 6D ug/cm^2 6 67.82 67.50 0.47
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_vaseline24h 8A ug/cm^2 5 8.77 8.75 0.25
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_vaseline96h 8B ug/cm^2 5 9.64 9.65 -0.10
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_imiquimod24h 8C ug/cm^2 5 43.45 43.30 0.34
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_imiquimod96h 8D ug/cm^2 5 35.62 35.50 0.34
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_ear_acetone 10A ug/cm^2 5 2.91 2.90 0.39
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_ear_tncb 10B ug/cm^2 5 4.08 4.08 0.12

Table 2 acceptance windows

Table 2 lists the a-posteriori acceptance window for the measured cumulative mass at the end of each healthy-skin experiment; replicates outside it were excluded before fitting. A faithful fit to the mean of the accepted replicates must end inside the window.

table2 <- tibble::tribble(
  ~model,                             ~lower, ~upper,
  "Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_rt6h",   20,     50,
  "Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_32c6h",  40,     75,
  "Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_rt12h",  80,     120,
  "Szederkenyi_2024_dexamethasone",   600,    1000,
  "Szederkenyi_2024_indomethacin",    100,    200,
  "Szederkenyi_2024_piroxicam",       1200,   2000,
  "Szederkenyi_2024_diclofenac",      50,     100
)
t2 <- final |>
  dplyr::select(model, mass_unit, cum_mass) |>
  dplyr::inner_join(table2, by = "model")
stopifnot(nrow(t2) == 7, all(t2$cum_mass > t2$lower & t2$cum_mass < t2$upper))
knitr::kable(t2, digits = 1)
model mass_unit cum_mass lower upper
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_rt6h ug/cm^2 36.9 20 50
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_32c6h ug/cm^2 61.0 40 75
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_rt12h ug/cm^2 100.8 80 120
Szederkenyi_2024_dexamethasone ng/cm^2 833.0 600 1000
Szederkenyi_2024_piroxicam ng/cm^2 1541.6 1200 2000
Szederkenyi_2024_indomethacin ng/cm^2 138.7 100 200
Szederkenyi_2024_diclofenac ug/cm^2 67.8 50 100

Disease effects stated in the text

Section 3.5 states that imiquimod raised the caffeine permeability “more than 4 times at 24 h, and more than 3.5 times at 96 h” over the time-matched vaseline controls; Section 3.6 states that allergic contact dermatitis raised the ear permeability by 30%.

end_of <- function(nm) final$cum_mass[final$model == nm]
ratios <- tibble::tibble(
  comparison = c("Imiquimod / vaseline, 24 h", "Imiquimod / vaseline, 96 h", "TNCB / acetone (ear)"),
  simulated_ratio = c(
    end_of("Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_imiquimod24h") / end_of("Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_vaseline24h"),
    end_of("Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_imiquimod96h") / end_of("Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_vaseline96h"),
    end_of("Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_ear_tncb") / end_of("Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_ear_acetone")
  ),
  paper = c("> 4", "> 3.5", "1.3")
)
stopifnot(
  ratios$simulated_ratio[1] > 4,
  ratios$simulated_ratio[2] > 3.5,
  ratios$simulated_ratio[3] > 1
)
knitr::kable(ratios, digits = 2)
comparison simulated_ratio paper
Imiquimod / vaseline, 24 h 4.95 > 4
Imiquimod / vaseline, 96 h 3.70 > 3.5
TNCB / acetone (ear) 1.40 1.3

The imiquimod ratios meet the stated thresholds. The ear ratio from the fitted curves at 5 h is about 1.4 rather than the stated 1.3; the measured curves of Figure 10 end at about 2.95 and 4.1 ug/cm^2, also a ratio near 1.4, so the paper’s 30% presumably comes from a different summary (for example the permeation rate over part of the experiment) that is not reported.

Closed-form solution and the eliminated model (Eqs 2-6)

Eq 1 is linear, x' = A x + b with b = (kin, 0, 0) and zero initial state, so x(t) = A^-1 (exp(A t) - I) b. The packaged ODE must match this to integration precision. The authors’ identifiability argument rewrites the model as y''' + theta1 y'' + theta2 y' + theta3 y + theta4 = 0 (Eqs 2-6); theta1..theta3 are the characteristic-polynomial coefficients of A, and the steady state of y is -theta4 / theta3 = kin / kout. Both identities are checked for every parameter set.

system_matrix <- function(kd, kc, kout) {
  matrix(c(
    -(kd + kc), kd, 0,
    kd + kc, -(2 * kd + kc), kd,
    0, kd + kc, -(kd + kout)
  ), nrow = 3, byrow = TRUE)
}
x3_closed_form <- function(times, kin, kd, kc, kout) {
  A <- system_matrix(kd, kc, kout)
  e <- eigen(A)
  vinv <- solve(e$vectors)
  b <- c(kin, 0, 0)
  vapply(times, function(t) {
    expAt <- Re(e$vectors %*% diag(exp(e$values * t)) %*% vinv)
    (solve(A, (expAt - diag(3)) %*% b))[3]
  }, numeric(1))
}
cf <- dplyr::bind_rows(lapply(seq_len(nrow(s1)), function(i) {
  p <- s1[i, ]
  s <- sim[sim$model == p$model, ]
  A <- system_matrix(p$kd, p$kc, p$kout)
  minors <- A[1, 1] * A[2, 2] - A[1, 2] * A[2, 1] +
    A[2, 2] * A[3, 3] - A[2, 3] * A[3, 2] +
    A[1, 1] * A[3, 3] - A[1, 3] * A[3, 1]
  theta <- c(
    2 * p$kc + 4 * p$kd + p$kout,
    p$kc^2 + 3 * p$kc * p$kd + 2 * p$kout * p$kc + 3 * p$kd^2 + 3 * p$kout * p$kd,
    p$kout * p$kc^2 + 2 * p$kout * p$kc * p$kd + p$kout * p$kd^2,
    -p$kin * (p$kc + p$kd)^2
  )
  tibble::tibble(
    model = p$model,
    ode_vs_closed_form = max(abs(s$cum_mass - x3_closed_form(s$time, p$kin, p$kd, p$kc, p$kout))) /
      max(s$cum_mass),
    theta_vs_charpoly = max(abs(c(-sum(diag(A)), minors, -det(A)) / theta[1:3] - 1)),
    steady_state = -theta[4] / theta[3],
    steady_state_vs_kin_over_kout = abs(-theta[4] / theta[3] / (p$kin / p$kout) - 1)
  )
}))
# The ODE-vs-closed-form error is integration error at rtol = 1e-10; the
# theta and steady-state identities are pure floating-point algebra.
stopifnot(
  all(cf$ode_vs_closed_form < 1e-6),
  all(cf$theta_vs_charpoly < 1e-10),
  all(cf$steady_state_vs_kin_over_kout < 1e-10)
)
knitr::kable(cf, digits = 12)
model ode_vs_closed_form theta_vs_charpoly steady_state steady_state_vs_kin_over_kout
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_rt6h 5.00e-12 0 2.538259e+02 0
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_32c6h 6.00e-12 0 6.148549e+02 0
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_rt12h 5.00e-12 0 2.183857e+05 0
Szederkenyi_2024_dexamethasone 4.73e-10 0 2.229877e+07 0
Szederkenyi_2024_piroxicam 6.10e-10 0 5.180022e+07 0
Szederkenyi_2024_indomethacin 3.00e-12 0 1.739182e+05 0
Szederkenyi_2024_diclofenac 0.00e+00 0 2.333953e+02 0
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_vaseline24h 7.90e-11 0 1.084666e+01 0
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_vaseline96h 2.10e-11 0 1.444404e+01 0
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_imiquimod24h 5.00e-12 0 3.305099e+04 0
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_imiquimod96h 1.00e-11 0 2.194808e+05 0
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_ear_acetone 0.00e+00 0 7.920873e+02 0
Szederkenyi_2024_caffeine_ear_tncb 6.00e-12 0 9.184466e+00 0

The steady-state column also shows why most curves in the paper still rise almost linearly at the end of the experiment: with kout as small as 1e-5 1/h, the deepest layer would only level off at kin / kout, far beyond the measured range.

Assumptions and deviations

  • One model per experiment. The paper fits the same structure separately to each of 13 experiments and reports 13 parameter sets with no shared parameters, so nlmixr2lib ships 13 models rather than one model with experiment indicators.
  • Compartment names. The three states x1..x3 are the layers of a spatially discretised diffusion-convection equation and are named with the method-of-lines family skin_slab1..skin_slab3, numbered from the skin surface inward. The slab count of 3 is fixed by the published fit, not a numerical choice, so no convergence check applies.
  • Parameter names. The paper’s kd (diffusion) and kc (convection) are stored as kdiff and kconv, because kd is the library’s name for a dissociation rate constant. kin and kout keep their names.
  • No variability or residual error. The authors fitted each mean curve by minimising a relative 2-norm (Eq 7) and report no residual-error magnitude, so the models carry typical values only and expose the output as the algebraic variable cum_mass without an error model. The minimum objective value V_min of each fit is recorded in the model’s population$notes.
  • Units. Time is in hours and the states are mass per cm^2 of diffusion surface, from the figure axes. The states are called concentrations in Section 2.7, but the fitted quantity is the cumulative mass. kin is in mass per cm^2 per hour.
  • Diclofenac units. Figure 6D and Table 2 both give diclofenac in ug/cm^2 (versus ng/cm^2 for the other three anti-inflammatory drugs), and the model follows them. Section 3.4 says diclofenac “penetrated in the lowest amount”, which would hold only if those values were ng/cm^2. The parameters are unaffected by the unit label except that kin scales with it.
  • Species of the healthy-skin experiments. Sections 2.4 and 2.6, the S2 and S3 Fig captions and Table 2 (rat body-weight window) state rat skin for the temperature and anti-inflammatory experiments; Section 3.2 and the captions of Figures 4-6 say mouse skin. The models follow the Methods.
  • Figure label in S1 Table. S1 Table labels the TNCB row as Figure “10.C”; Figure 10 has panels A and B only, and the TNCB curve is Figure 10B.
  • Model provenance citation. Section 2.7 describes Eq 1 as a modified form of Eqs 55-57 of the paper’s reference 1, which in the published reference list is a tacrolimus molecular-modelling study; the citation appears to be misnumbered. Eq 1 is printed in full, so the extraction does not depend on it.
  • Constant input. kin is constant from time zero, i.e. the cream acts as an infinite-dose donor; the applied amount is not reported.
  • No correction notice is linked to the article in Europe PMC as of 2026-10-29.